What does it mean to be sober or in recovery? This has become a live question as more people identify as being in recovery or having sobriety from the use of one substance while still also using other substances occasionally or without the challenges typical of an addiction or Substance Use Disorder (SUD). Someone who identifies as an alcoholic might use cannabis products in a recreational way. Someone in recovery from a heroin addiction may enjoy an occasional glass of wine. Others who have past struggles with a substance may now be able to consume it with no apparent troubles. All of these scenarios have been lumped into the phenomenon of “California Sober.” But for as many people cheer this perspective, there are just as many who jeer it, and others who are simply confused by it.
Abstinence, Sobriety, and Recovery
The confusion stems, in part, from the common usage of those terms, which has been shaped by Alcoholics Anonymous (AA). For decades, AA’s 12-step model has dominated in- and out-patient treatment centers; almost 75% of treatment involves the steps. While the model does not explicitly require abstinence—the only requirement for AA membership is an expressed desire to stop drinking—it is strongly recommended throughout the literature and fellowship of AA.
In many ways, through the 12 steps, abstinence, sobriety, and recovery are conceived as different but tightly related activities. There are no formal definitions but typically abstinence means categorically saying No to a substance. In saying No, the substance may still play a huge role in your life, but while consuming the substance was once a primary activity, now not consuming it is one’s primary activity. In sobriety, ideally, the substance is no longer the axis around which so many of one’s goals or activities revolve. Sobriety changes a person’s relationship to the substance and the roles it plays in their life. Recovery is having the skills, arts, and willingness to change one’s life in ways to make different meanings and values; it’s a way of life. For a “old-school” AAer, abstinence is the first and necessary step to creating sobriety and living in recovery. and they would likely deny that a person who still uses other substances is sober or in recovery.
Harm Reduction
Why should this view of abstinence —> sobriety —> recovery remain dominant even as other approaches to treating SUDs gain traction in research, public policy, and popular thought? Harm reduction argues for lessening the harms that come from misusing drugs through a variety of means. Abstinence is one method among others such as the use of medically approved substitutes (Suboxone or methadone for heroin, e.g.) and lowering/lightening consumption patterns. Harm reduction would suggest that people can identify as being in recovery while not abstaining from all substances.
There’s deep suspicion in some corners of recovery communities, however, about the use of medically approved and dispensed/administered substitutes. For those who believe complete abstinence is the only path to sobriety and recovery, reliance on a substitute such as Suboxone or methadone is not only not abstinence but represents active addiction. The most uncharitable view is that a person is just switching addictive substances.
I believe this is unfair. If the use of medically approved substances can stave off withdrawal effects or reduce cravings and therefore enable a person to function more fully and healthfully in her life, to be more responsible and engaged with herself and others, she is living a very different life from before. Is she sober and in recovery? I believe she is.
SUDs on the Spectrum
The decision by the American Psychiatric Association to classify SUDs on a spectrum also questions the relationship between abstinence, sobriety, and recovery. Someone is diagnosed with a SUD depending on the number of criteria she meets. There are 11 diagnostic criteria for SUDs; a person has a “mild” SUD if she meets 2-3 criteria. A person who meets 4-5 has a “moderate” SUD while a person who meets more than 6 has a “severe” disorder. Interestingly, the term “addiction” is nowhere to be found in these diagnoses, perhaps because it carries too much stigma. However, the word is still widely used by medical and treatment professionals, in the legal system, and in popular culture. So, who is an addict: A person with a mild SUD? A moderate SUD? Or should the term be reserved only for those who have a severe SUD? If someone scores a 3, makes changes to her consumption, and later doesn’t meet a single criterion, was she ever addicted? Does she still have a SUD? Let’s say her substance of choice was alcohol. Is an occasional glass of wine a slip or relapse?
It gets more complicated with moderate and severe SUDs. Imagine a person who meets 5 criteria for a SUD and then she, too, changes her consumption patterns and her relationship to alcohol. Her life gets better, she has reduced the harm in her life, and no longer meets any criteria for an SUD. The same questions that arise above are at play here. Let’s imagine she walks her criteria back to a 3, so she is still is in the range of a mild SUD. Cam she declare herself sober? In recovery? Many would say she is not if she is not abstinent. I think it is more complicated: If she has changed many of the dynamics and dimensions of her relationship to the substance and the role it plays in her life, is able to do much more to meet her major responsibilities in life, and is living better, then she is recovering parts of herself and life that she had lost due to the consumption of her substance.
How about the person who meets 7 criteria for a diagnosis of a severe SUD but walks it back to a moderate SUD? That represents a significant reduction in harm and surely counts for something. Compared to how she was before, she is more able to participate in her life. She has far fewer days of using or uses far less than before. Compared to before, she is sober more often. But does sober more often equal sober?
This is about more than splitting hairs. It really does matter how people see and understand themselves and how they present to others. I have heard some people in AA claim that “California sobriety” makes a mockery of their own sobriety and recovery. This makes it deeply personal for them. Others report that they fear people who embrace California sobriety are deceiving themselves. Those who subscribe to harm reduction, though, believe that it improvements in people’s lives matter, and not how others label them.
As someone in recovery, my greatest concern is that we are all pulling in the same direction to lessen suffering. Different approaches will work for different people. People may need different approaches in their lives; what worked for them a year ago may no longer. This is not a zero-sum game.
Originally published on psychologytoday.com August 22, 2025
