It seems strange to say that people need to take an interest in themselves. In this age of social media, people tend to overshare the minutiae of their lives. Everything a person may do becomes post or status update worthy—what they are eating, reading, and watching on television, when they are waiting in an airport, and what their dog is doing (I plead guilty on this particular charge). It seems as if many people are taking a ton of interest in themselves. They are also assuming that others will share the same interest in and fascination with them. As we all know, that often is not the case.
Oversharing on social media doesn’t make a person better or happier; it may make her less happy because she becomes even more reliant on the approval of others. Her self-esteem or worthiness may now be quantified in the number of likes or views her posts receive. Oversharing the mundane matters may make it harder to share the important ones well, appropriately, and responsibly. Oversharing makes it really difficult to apprehend the relationship between the forest and the trees.
There are all sorts of ways that people can take interests in themselves, but they are not all equal to the task of helping someone to become a better person. Having a concern to become a better person is one of the most crucial forms that self-interest can take; it is necessary for well-being. Call this Self Interest Aiming toward Moral Betterment (SIAMB). SIAMB is antithetical to selfishness because it tends to be as much other-regarding as self-regarding. The roots for SIAMB are found in Ancient Greece; a person’s moral character is inseparable from the relationships she has with particular others. By doing more generous and trustworthy things with or for friends, for example, a person becomes more generous and trustworthy. Her character improves. This is far from selfish; selfish interests are those that aim toward the primary or sole benefit of a person without much concern for the effect on others.
Some people have an extraordinarily hard time making this distinction between SIAMB and selfishness. For example, many women have been socialized to put their interests far behind the interests of their husbands, children, parents, complete strangers, and the neighbor’s pet ferret, etc. When they do act in ways that involve putting their SIAMB towards the top of the queue, they may face the accusation, “you’re being selfish.” This accusation is a powerfully effective tool of control and manipulation because it taps into deeply gendered norms. It is even more effective because women often internalize this view and can deliver the devastating judgment early and often.
Others who have been abused and traumatized may also have a hard time taking the right sort of interest in themselves. This may also be true for people who have moved down the spectrum of Substance use Disorders. To be able to see that one has a legitimate interest in herself requires that she see herself as having moral worth. One of the most debilitating effects of abuse and trauma and severe addiction is that one can lose the sense that she is a moral being and as such has a certain dignity and autonomy that should be respected by others and by herself. Respecting her own dignity may seem as possible to her as dancing a waltz on the moon.
Much rides on people being able to take the right sort of self-interest for their own well-being. Without SIAMB, people tend to self-abnegate; their concerns will recede so far into the background that they may become foreign, unrecognizable, and even hostile. Not having an ample reservoir of appropriate self-interest may also lead to a person giving up on her life; she’ll take fewer and fewer actions on her own behalf because, well, why bother? Ultimately, she may lose her will to live.
How does one begin to cultivate SIAMB? I wish I had some definite answers. My “answers” are more impressionistic suggestions. For many people, having SIAMB is a hard won achievement that may need to be jump started by someone else. In The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), William James mentions the founder of The Salvation Army who understood that the first step in helping the “outcasts” (a very loaded and offensive term) was to “make them feel that some decent human being cares enough for them to take in interest in the question whether they are to rise or sink.” Some people cannot take that interest in themselves. The suggestion is that others having that interest in whether I rise or sink may help me generate that interest in myself. In other words, it is by witnessing and experiencing others having an interest in my life may I begin to have an interest in whether I rise or sink.
Another way that the seeds for SIAMB can take root is by encountering situations in which others are as worse off or even less fortunate than you. You then have an opportunity to be that “decent human being” who cares about whether someone else rises or sinks. There is great truth that witnessing the suffering of others often pulls a person out of her own misery. This is especially true when one sees that she could do something about it. She begins to act and her actions begin to feed her sense of worth and dignity.
Originally published on psychologytoday.com June 16, 2015