Is There Such a Thing as an Addictive Personality?

by | Addictive substances and behaviors? | 0 comments

Key points

  • Some people who do not drink claim to have an “alcoholic’s” or “addictive” personality.
  • Addictive personality is not a recognized medical condition.
  • The argument about addictive personalities rests on unjustified assumptions and reinforces stereotypes.
  • Moral philosophy offers a richer approach to explaining and evaluating behavior.

Can a person who has never drunk in troubling or addictive ways have an “alcoholic’s personality“? Does such a thing even exist? What role does it play in explaining anyone else’s behavior?

The expression “alcoholic’s personality” has been in the news recenty because Susie Wiles, President Trump’s Chief of Staff, said in an interview with Vanity Fair magazine that President Trump has it. She claimed, “high-functioning alcoholics or alcoholics in general, their personalities are exaggerated when they drink. And so I’m a little bit of an expert in big personalities.”

She adds that Trump believes that “there’s nothing he can’t do. Nothing, zero, nothing.” Wiles acknowledges that the experience she brings to bear on the matter comes from her late father, former professional football player and commentator, Pat Summerall, who had lived with alcoholism.

Trump agreed with Wiles’s assessment after it became public. He stated in the New York Post that “I’m fortunate I am not a drinker. If I did, I could very well, because I’ve said that—what’s the word? Not possessive—possessive and addictive type personality. Oh, I’ve said it many times, many times before.”

Addictive personalities

The expression “addictive personality” is more commonly used than “alcoholic’s personality,” but they share ancestry although neither is a recognized medical condition. An addictive personality is generally understood to be a constellation of psychological characteristics, health conditions, and environmental factors.

An addictive personality comprises a range of traits and behaviors including impulsivity, risk-taking, thrill-seeking, overindulgence, difficulty in self-regulation, preferring short-term benefits over long-term ones, engaging in obsessive or compulsive behaviors, difficulty in accepting limitations or constraints, and unwillingness to take responsibility. Some might also include comfort with lying and deception. These traits allegedly explain why some people develop an addiction.

In a significant sense, addiction gets defined by these traits regardless of any substances used, including alcohol, cocaine, and heroin, or behaviors such as gambling, scrolling TikTok for hours, etc. Thus, it’s understandable for Wiles to say it about President Trump and for him to agree, but this is an argument that needs to be unpacked because it is has several logical and practical flaws.

Flaws in the argument about addictive personalities

The first significant flaw of the argument is the reliance on a generalization. For a generalization to be justified, it must be based on a large representative sample. Wiles’s generalization is based on a very small and not representative sample pool. Very familiar stereotypes do the heavy lifting in her generalization, which in turn reinforce the stereotypes taken as evidence. For example, many alcoholics or addicts do not believe there is nothing they can’t do.

The second issue with Wiles’s argument, and the media’s parroting of it, is the reliance on circular characterization. Here’s the circle: If one has all or most of these traits, one has an addiction, and having an addiction means one has all or most of the traits. Stereotypes and their use in unjustified generalizations are taken as evidence of the circular relationship.

An argument that goes in circles is an instance of begging the question, the third flaw in the argument. An argument that begs the question is one in which a premise of the argument assumes the truth of the conclusion. Someone who claims, “Wilson tennis balls are superior to Penn because they have Wilson’s fiber technology,” begs the question. They don’t offer actual evidence for the superiority of Wilson’s technology, which would support the claim they’re the better tennis ball. This circular characterization is simply assumed in the relationship between “addictive personality” and “addiction.” This assumption needs much more evidence than it presently has.

Such arguments can lead to harmful conclusions in the real world. “Addictive personality” sounds like an objective condition, but it may be a dangerous fiction as it creates and reinforces stereotypes that serve as the basis for generalizations that then pass as medical or common knowledge. The circle just gets more vicious.

What moral philosophy offers

There is no need to invoke the fiction of an addictive or alcoholic personality to morally explain and evaluate someone’s behavior. We have plenty of concepts from a variety of moral traditions that should be used instead. We might look to Aristotle and Confucius, who focus on virtue and character, arguing that we become who we are by what we do repeatedly. Present acts spring from a moral character formed over a lifetime.

Immanuel Kant offers the categorical imperative. One formulation is: Never act in such a way that we treat humanity, whether in ourselves or in others, as a means only but always as an end in itself. In other words, don’t use people and treat them as pawns for your own benefit or enrichment, but rather act in ways that respect others’ autonomy and dignity. Rights, fairness, impartiality, and equality have their genesis in this tradition.

We can draw from relationship ethics that prioritize healthy and respectful relations with ourselves and other humans near and far, as well as with animals and the Earth itself. Relationship ethics asks us how to think about our inalienable responsibilities to these others.

Ascribing someone’s behaviors to an addictive personality is far too easy to do because it functions as shorthand. We need to use rich, varied, and complex moral concepts to explain and evaluate behavior instead.

Originally published on psychologytoday.com October 9, 2026